Powered by Phile | Already have an account? Register Sign In

To help keep the forums organized, choose some tags to characterize this question.

Tags:

6 followers
My wife and I want to go to wine country for 2 days 1 night in March. We haven't settled on the exact area (Napa? Sonoma? Calistoga?), but I was curious as to where we should go for a special dinner.

To give a sense of our tastes, we love Saison, but we don't like Benu, which tastes too fussy, processed and bland to us. We love Coi but we're not such fans of its atmosphere. In general, we love ingredient driven food that is creative, while still tasting like food.

Any thoughts?
Tags: date night, wine country   

sho
sho Mon 14 Feb 2011 18:05:05 GMT
Related Questions
Tags: wine country | 9 Replies
Sat 17 Dec 2011 05:05:43 GMT
No replies
Thu 04 Apr 2013 01:21:20 GMT
1 Reply
Thu 10 Jan 2013 01:21:43 GMT
6 Replies
Fri 23 Mar 2012 21:17:25 GMT
Answers (4)
tablehopper
tablehopper Wed 16 Feb 2011 01:26:17 GMT

One of my favorite wine country places is Cyrus in Healdsburg--and Hburg is a great place to stay since there's so much good eating up there (Flying Goat Coffee, Downtown Bakery, and more: check out my Healdsburg writeups here: http://www.tablehopper.com/jetsetter/healdsburg/). Chef Douglas Keane is an amazing chef, with just enough elegance balanced against creativity, so each dish is something unique. Nice Japanese/Asian elements in his cuisine, too

sho Wed 16 Feb 2011 01:35:34 GMT
Sounds good. Jean and I have spent a lot of time in Healdsburg (her aunt owns a house there) but we've never been to Cyrus. On the one hand, it looks like a great place, but on the other hand, people seem to love Benu and we don't, so I didn't know if it was more on the refined / manipulated / restrained tip that Benu was on...

Also, any thoughts on other places? Auberge du Soleil?
sho Wed 16 Feb 2011 01:35:52 GMT
And thanks, Marcia!
tablehopper Wed 16 Feb 2011 01:51:19 GMT
Cyrus is not as restrained as Benu--refined, yes, but not as manipulated. The food is just amazing, truly.

I was also thinking about how much I enjoyed my meal at Madrona Manor--there are a couple molecular dishes, but overall the food is fab. And I loved the Victorian mansion and grounds--it's great to stay there so you can just toddle off to bed. And the tableside cheese cart, ice cream service, and coffee service can't be beat. It's a gem.

And then you have to go to Diavola for pizza the next day in Geyserville!
Joelle Tue 22 Feb 2011 23:44:55 GMT
Cyrus is a special place. Many Tricks( golden balloon and cloche) and treats that make it a standout-special occasion place. Menu selection was beautifully presented and carefully constructed, service elegant with warmth. Many courses with AM food hangover predicted. For 2 with paired wines and tip around $800.
artybee
artybee Wed 23 Feb 2011 05:26:30 GMT
Bistro GiovanniAdd this place

On Highway 29 just north of Napa.  It doesn't look promising from Hwy 29, but it faces east, away from the road.  When you arrive at night it feels like a sophisticated well-lit city dining room, only it's out in the vineyards. 

The room seems like a giant Cliff May ranch house done over by tastefully-savvy Italians--it's romantic, festive, art-lined, and lofty.  It's always filled with people who seem like they all know eachother and were personally invited by the owners, and you'll feel like that too. 

The food is very good, but nothing super-innovative or pretentious.  Just unfussy upscale delicious Italian done perfectly.  Delicious, really.  Even some of the dishes that might not evoke excitement (like tutti di mare pasta) really shine here.  The excitement comes from the flavors, not the menu descriptions.

Don't go expecting a revelation, or anything too vertical or foams or too small for a second bite.  Do expect both comfort and excitement and a good bottle of wine.

There's a nice outdoor area too if you're there for lunch or on a balmy summer night. 

sho Wed 23 Feb 2011 05:34:39 GMT
I ate at Bistro Don Giovanni 10+ years ago when I was a young college grad who had just moved to the Bay Area. I think I may have even gone there with the woman who would eventually become my wife, but I don't remember...

Glad to hear it's still there and still good.
artybee
artybee Wed 23 Feb 2011 05:05:51 GMT

Amazing Michelin starred vegetarian that even omnivores such as myself love.  They grow many of their ingredients in their garden upvalley, and what they don't grow is always organic and often unusual.  Some of the dishes are so rich and complex it's hard to believe there is no meat stock used. For 2. order 3-4 dishes and share family style. 

Caveat: I haven't been since the chef departed last year, but I haven't heard that the quality has slipped, and I spend lots of time in the Valley.  It's right in Downtown Napa.

sho Wed 23 Feb 2011 05:22:06 GMT
I was always sad not to have eaten here before Jeremy Fox left. Has anyone else been here since then? Reports?
artybee Wed 23 Feb 2011 05:30:22 GMT
I was sad he left too. Have you been to Primal Napa? He was there last year roasting vegetables next to all the meat guys. Really fun, but not for vegetarians.
sho Wed 23 Feb 2011 05:32:34 GMT
Ha ha!I don't get up to Napa very often. I live in the city and I'm often in Sonoma because my wife has a house up there. And I have two kids. And, and, and.. (the excuses continue)
coopet
coopet Tue 22 Feb 2011 23:49:06 GMT

Ask to sit in the inside room or outdoors on a nice day/evening. Beautiful atmosphere

tablehopper Tue 22 Feb 2011 23:56:01 GMT
I really like Bottega--some clever dishes, wonderful ingredients, and such tender octopus, crazy good.
histon Wed 23 Feb 2011 05:43:43 GMT
I love bottega, it is such a flexible venue and everything tastes good. Agree ask to sit inside...
Add an answer
To answer this question yourself, sign in or create an account.